Sunday, September 4, 2016

Katie Gerstenberg: Blog 2

My experience with genre writing is a tad unique. I did not start learning about different types of genre writing until I began college four years ago. Back in high school, I attended a prestigious catholic school, Cathedral Catholic High School. I'm not saying their views were "narrow minded," but everything seemed to be their way, or the high way. Everything I wrote was professional, strict formatting, perfect, or else you did not receive the grade you had opted for. When I started college, I learned about several styles of writing, and I absolutely loved it.
Referring to the reading Devitt, I find it admirable that it was noted that it was acknowledged that "as rhetorical forms that come to feel normal, genres seem too thoroughly ideological to be taught in classrooms that aim to enable students to create their own universes within their existing political and social structures" (340). This caught my eye because teachers and professors can guide a student to become a good writer; however, their own ideas, experiences, and memories are what creates that outstanding paper. Each genre comes with a guideline on how it should turn out, but each individual adds their own "spice" to the paper that cannot be taught, for interpersonal experiences makes a genuine, unique, credible paper. My experiences with genres is that I was never allowed to be personable due to the format and expectations that were carried out throughout my time in high school. With that being said, I am looking forward to the opportunity to expand my knowledge on writing in this course this semester.
To me, Devitt describes "genre" as an umbrella term that is filled with social, cultural, individual, historical ideas and norms. Genre is such a broad term that provides all opportunities to expand writing to get a point or story across. Now that I have spent four years in college, I have been given several opportunities to expand within genres. For example, in my upper division courses, I write several research papers in APA format, and in other lower division writing courses I have been given a chance to write other styles of writing such as persuasion, philosophical, and so forth. Outside of school, I have written several personal stories, and I have written documentations for legal purposes. As I take my next step applying for grad school, I will be perfecting my cover letter, and asking professors to write me letters of recommendations. I will be writing papers on "why I want to be affiliated in this graduate program."
Devitt explains the idea of genre awareness and how important it is by correlating it to our own critical consciousness, "developing genre awareness is no easier than developing any other kind of critical consciousness" (348). Devitt explains that once a genre is learned, the goal is to use it at a level where its natural to step into that genre and write and discuss it. Genre awareness is critical because the more we are familiar with the style of writing we are writing and reading, we can develop a better relationship to the author, or if it is us writing that genre, we can help relate to the reader.
In my personal experience, the more comfortable we are in a style of writing, it is easier to get our point or story across when we are familiar with what we are doing. My first time writing in any different environment makes me feel like a robot, but over time and the more I right I feel at ease and can actually get my thoughts and feelings across.
Thats all I got on Devitt!
Thanks for reading!

5 comments:

  1. In your blog, you describe genres as providing a framework for writing, but you also mention that it is up to the writer to use their own creativity in what they build around this framework. I am glad you mentioned this. In her article, Devitt made it sound as if the structure of genre confined creativity, but I agree that creativity can still prosper within the frames of established genre. You mentioned that the more a person becomes familiar with a genre, the more effectively it can be used. As a person gains greater mastery over a genre, the more they can then expand upon it to create something unique. I also agree with your assertion that creativity can be limited, depending upon whether or not a person has been exposed to a variety of genres, or just a select few. More exposure means more potential for creativity.

    - Joseph Cashman

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Katie!

    I enjoyed reading your blog. I too felt the constraint from my high school to follow a specific format and guidelines. I am not quite sure what your high school required, but as I mentioned in my blog, I thought the five paragraph essay was the end all be all. It was the format that I have always used in order to write essays. So just like you, when I started going to college I learned various genres and how to write them.

    I also really like how you concluded your blog. I am right there with you about the more you do something the more comfortable you are and ultimately the better you become. With this whole blog thing I feel so strange writing this way. It is not exactly formal but also not informal because it is still a college assignment. So it is hard as of right now to find that happy medium.

    You did a great job on explaining Devitt!
    See you in class,
    Allison Starr

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Katie!

    After reading your blog understanding what Devitt said in her article made more sense. Like yourself my knowledge of genres were nothing more than high school teachings on whether it should be a narrative or persuasive essay. This is my first week at San Diego State so my knowledge on genres is that of what I learned at community college. However like you mentioned from Devitts reading the more we become familiar with a style of writing the easier it becomes use in our everyday writings. In one instant we can greatly underestimate a specific genre or on the other hand it may seem as familiar as reading a meme it all depends on how we familiarize ourselves with said genre. For me as a new transfer coming from community I still have a lot to learned during my stay at SDSU.

    Sincerely,

    David Bobadilla

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Katie!
    I am glad that you added your own personal experience in how you were taught how to write essays. I never knew that catholic schools would be strict even on how to write essays also. You included a point that I did not see about genre awareness. You saw the genre awareness as being closer to the author and I thought of it as just adding more variety to our lives. Also, that we should familiarize ourselves with different genres so that we do not feel like a robot. The fact that in your four years you have been able to write different types of genres because you were able to move to another institution, San Diego State University, provides hope for other students to be able to escape the never ending train of writing only 5 paragraphs. I also find it true that being more aware of different genres allows the writer to put more feeling into it and be able to get our point or claim across.

    All the best,
    Lisset Perales

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really appreciated your personal experience with the high school essay, how it didn't allow you to be personable or creative at all. As I'm thinking about this, I see how stifling this can be to students who really want to put some of themselves into their writing. I used to incorporate a lot of free writes into my classes but cut those out in order to reduce reading. I wonder if that's a good plan. (Then again, what student wants MORE homework?)

    Anyway. Thanks for giving me something to think about. EF

    ReplyDelete